...

[lyssie]

Dear reviewers of Cauterized People.

No. The Asgard are not going to fucking fix Sam. In what world is it going to make her psychologically healthy to get pregnant? NONE.

Considering past evidence, it would probably cause a psychological break, and she'd kill herself. End of story.

Love, Lyssie.

Comments

[surreallis.livejournal.com]

You are one of those dark, sick ppl spoken of in whispers on the list, aren't you?

I soooo hope you are. :p

[lyssie.livejournal.com]

*makes a face*

Yes. I'm one of those people who will one day write the SGC dying in a bloodbath as Sam snaps from eight years of UST..

er.

Actually, I'm the one who was unimpressed (I can't help it. Benway wrote skullfucking, once) at the darkness of most fic. Though Tafkar does a damn fine job of it.
(Reply to this)(Parent)

[surreallis.livejournal.com]

Ah yes, I remember. ;)

I was actually going to reply to your post a day or two back about darkfic, but then I didn't and time went by and it seemed a little late. It's just rather interesting as to what various fans consider to be darkfic. As an example, I wouldn't necessarily consider any rape fic to be darkfic... unless it happens between two memebers of SG-1.

It also seems to differ between fandoms as you've stated. I remember a thread I was in once about blood being used as a sexual lubricant in Buffy fics. (I've never seen an episode) It's not unusual in that fandom but, damn, if blood as a lubricant was used in SG-1... that's definitely pretty damn dark for SG. (And so ridiculous as well since it's SO not a lubricant in any sense of the word... but I digress...)

I guess there's a line between heavy angst and darkfic as well, as faded as it may be. Just wondering if you had some thoughts. On that.

[lyssie.livejournal.com]

I think dark psychologically also fits in.

My main problem was that, reading most of the fic it was either really bad bdsm porn (I've read better on erotic story archives) that turned Sam into an object, rape fic where Sam was a wimp who could not defend herself (which, uh, hello, she IS in the AF, she DOES have training for that sort of thing), or... well, actually, that was it. Except for the one where Jack tortured a guy to death. And I did kinda like that one.

Oh! And one crappy Ba'al torturing Jack by sodomy fic.

Sigh.

I'm sure there's good dark SGC fic out there. I just... haven't really seen it.

And blood as a lubricant is like using superglue as a lubricant. Or spit.

[karma-aster.livejournal.com]

(cringing)Guh! No! Blood as a lubricant! Ouch! Bad! Gross! Painful!

And, no, even Thor can't fix Sam. And it makes me sad because I believe that Thor can do nearly anything.

(whimpers)My poor beloved Thor...

Not even Jack's HeroPenis can make her unbroken. But it can make her forget for a little while. So...that helps.

[surreallis.livejournal.com]

Yes, I agree. Darkfic doesn't mean you can just get rid of every shred of familiarity of a character. Not without a damn good reason anyway. Convince me of why they're acting that way and sure. I'm pretty easy that way.

You know, there's not enough dark Daniel fic. He's got some shit going on. If anyone is going to shift a bit off kilter and get up to something... it's him. *g*